The Dirty Nil – Minimum R & B


Whatever you do, don’t call The Dirty Nil a punk band! To be a part of modern day punk can often mean to paradoxically fight conformity, yet adhere to a strict code of conduct that alienates anyone who disagrees. The Dirty Nil just want to hoist up their guitars, get drunk, and yell in your face for almost forty minutes. On the surface, they make the same amount of noise as their punk brethren, but their newest release Minimum R & B succeeds in showing that at their core, they are truly a bunch of swaggering, bratty, no-good rockers.

If you aren’t familiar with The Dirty Nil, they are kind of a big deal. They recently won the 2017 Juno Award for Breakthrough Group of the Year, and statistically, you wouldn’t be wrong in thinking that they would polish up and go mainstream. On Minimum R & B, they pretty much go backward instead. The album isn’t even really a new release though. It’s a compilation that cherry picks from EPs Little Metal Baby Fist and SMITE, and features stand-alone singles as well as one never before heard track.

It may seem that The Dirty Nil are capitalizing on their newfound success, and really who could blame them? Getting rock heard these days is not a particularly easy endeavor! That said, Minimum R & B is a must-have purchase for new fans (like myself) and devoted followers who want to hear the new track “Caroline,” and have all their old favourites in one place. In essence, this is a record that is sure to please everybody.

Even though they are abrasive – attitude is valued over virtuosity – The Dirty Nil are right in saying that they really aren’t a punk band. If anything, what they do here reminds me of The Replacements debut album Sorry Ma, Forgot To Take Out The Trash, in that their style is more akin to sped-up, slightly more sloppy classic rock. They also seem to be channeling Pinkerton-era Weezer, in that there are big, quirky hooks under all the piercing feedback, and raspy yelling.

If there is any qualm I have about the record, it’s that the production value evolves so much throughout their first six years that there is a HUGE difference between something like opener “Fuckin’ Up Young” and closer “Caroline.” It doesn’t make for a particularly cohesive listen, but it is fun to hear how the band’s sound evolved throughout the years, all while sticking to similar lyrical themes. They were always brash, young, and defiant! Growing doesn’t have to break your heart after all!

As far as compilations go, this really should be treated as a real, complete album. It is haphazard, smacked together, and may cause whiplash, but what good rock music doesn’t? I’m actually still kind of amazed that these guys have had as much success as they have had! How did something so organically produced gain so much industry acceptance?! Higher Power might still be their best, and most popular album, but this is a way better introduction. Songs like “Fuckin’ Up Young,” “Guided By Vices,” and “Caroline” are an excellent indication of where these guys have been, are, and will continue to go. If you like raw, pretension free rock music, then pick this up now! Just don’t call it punk!

Written by Shawn Thicke
*edited by Kate Erickson


About Shawn Thicke 114 Articles
Since the age of 12, Shawn Thicke has had an unhealthy addiction to music consumption and the need to offer his opinion to anyone willing to listen. Thankfully, since writing at Bucketlist Music Reviews, his needs have been met much to the relief of those close to him. Not only is he an avid listener, but music has pretty much taken over the rest of his life as well. His love of the stage has ensured that he is constantly busy as the lead singer and lyricist of local rock bands Rustic State and Thicke Sugar. The former you can find playing on any given weekend all over the city of Montreal. During the day though, he becomes a member of society and works as a music teacher at the Montreal Oral School for the Deaf. Shawn hopes to one day find success with his own music, but until that day comes you'll be sure to see him at your show, bopping his head with a goofy grin on his face.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.